Shokhrukh Kayumov – Co-founder of Fratelli Casa, Promowear, TextileFinds.com, 16 years in the textile industry
Recently, we often hear terms like “online store,” “marketplace,” or “e-commerce.” Many offline retailers think that online sales are now better than offline. That it’s essential to appear on marketplaces like Amazon, Wildberries, Uzum, Ozon, Lamoda, or to create your own online store. But what is the reality?
First of all, it depends on your goals and the type of product you have. If your plan is to sell large volumes with low margins and brand development is not a priority, marketplaces are the better option. They love sellers like this. The goal of marketplace owners is to offer customers a wide assortment at affordable prices. Customers go to marketplaces to save time and money, without expecting any particular brand experience.
However, if you have a niche product with a high margin and brand promotion is important, you need your own online store. Marketplaces are not interested in promoting your brand; they always think about the customer. Let’s look more closely at how algorithms work on different platforms.
Amazon works in such a way that if your product sells well, or if customers frequently view a particular product image, it will appear in the top search results for some time. But then sales may suddenly drop. Why? The site’s algorithm finds a similar product at an even lower price and places it next to yours in the search results.
As I mentioned, marketplaces focus on the customer — to make them happy with the purchase and encourage them to return. From experience: we sold a T-shirt on Amazon for $15.99 until a similar T-shirt appeared near our listing for $9.99. If the product is unbranded, the customer will simply choose the cheaper option.
Wildberries’ algorithm promotes products with low prices and large stock volumes. If your stock is small, your product will appear further down — because for the marketplace, it’s important that in-demand products continue to sell for a long time.
Marketplaces also have their own private labels (PL), which they launch based on sales analytics. The platforms own all the data and know what sells well. Most of the top product pages are usually dominated by their own items. Amazon doesn’t hide this, which is why many brands frequently sue the company.
By the way, analytics can be monetized. While you are preparing a collection for a marketplace, other sellers may create similar products based on analytics purchased from the marketplaces themselves.
It’s also important to remember that what sells is not just the clothing in the photo, but a well-designed product listing. I once saw statistics from a seller in Moscow showing which T-shirts sold best and how much profit they made. By slightly adjusting the design or lowering the price, sales could change. Customers usually don’t remember the brand and may buy a similar product from a competitor next time if it appears higher in search or costs less. That’s why marketplaces often have a high number of similar items.
In contrast, your own online store allows you to collect valuable data about your customers: what sizes they buy, what price points they prefer, and seasonal trends. You can use this data to offer products through other sales channels. On marketplaces, you don’t have this information — you don’t know who your customers are and cannot, for example, retarget ads to them later.
Another significant drawback of marketplaces is that you must comply with their rules. For example, during holidays, everyone expects discounts. If the marketplace declares a sale, all sellers must participate. Refusing could even lead to temporary account suspension.
Marketplaces are great for a quick start and testing hypotheses with minimal investment. How long you stay there depends on your goals. If you aim to grow your business, it’s better to create your own online store in parallel. If you’re unsure about staying in this space long-term, have no budget for promotion, and your product is fairly standard, it’s more profitable to collaborate with marketplaces, earning without significant investment or effort.
In any case, it’s worth developing your own sales channels so you don’t become dependent on a marketplace. There’s always a risk of being blocked, even by mistake.
Marketplaces should be used strategically. For example, you can sell discounted products there. If they attract customers, those buyers may search for and visit your own store. This is a good promotion strategy.
For instance, we sell on Uzum with a very limited collection. Customers who see us there often find our website through search engines. That was our main strategy on Uzum. If your product is generic, you can promote your brand through social media and link to your marketplace page.
After working on various marketplaces, we eventually created our own online store. I recommend Shopify — it’s like a website builder where you can easily add products and adjust layouts. No programmer is needed. Our site cost about $2,000. We promote it via social media targeting, spending roughly $1,000–$1,500 per month. Simple math: the percentages paid to marketplaces (sometimes up to 40% of sales) can be spent on promoting your own site.
As you can see, both options have pros and cons. It’s essential to clearly understand your goals and product type. Is your product generic or does it have a unique feature? Are your goals short-term or long-term? Do you need a CRM to grow sales? If you’re not yet in online sales, start planning today. Wishing you successful sales!

















































































































